The Danger of Demographics: How Cultural Stereotypes Could Affect Your Conversions

Every time we go to the doctor’s office, are asked to take a survey, or register to win a car, we’re asked the same questions…..gender, age, race, ethnicity, education, income, marital status (I love that my pediatrician’s office has this on their questionnaire!),

Social science calls those characteristics “demographics” – the study of a population based on certain factors, like the ones mentioned above. And demographics are widely used in all industries – they help determine economic policy, where to build schools and hospitals, what products are available in stores, and where politicians make their campaign stops.

Now in marketing we talk a lot about the “ideal customer avatar,” our “target customer,” or our “buyer persona.” Having a crystal clear picture of the perfect buyer helps us design our products, craft our marketing campaigns, and ensure that the decisions we make are done so with our ideal customer avatar, or ICA, in mind.

The problem is that many business owners base their ICA strictly on demographics. Anytime I speak with a potential client, one of my first questions is, “Who is your audience? Who is your ideal customer avatar?” And 90% of the time, I get a response that goes something like this, “Our target customer is a single male, ages 35-45, with thinning hair who works 80 hours a week in the manufacturing industry.”

At a high level, that information is good to have – it’s a lot easier to talk to that guy than to every guy, right? But stop for a moment and think of the cultural stereotypes that accompany that demographic sketch.

  • Single male – Well, single guys like to party, drink, go out with the guys, looking for a date but not a long-term relationship
  • Age 35-50 – If he’s single and in this age bracket, then he must be enjoying the single lifestyle and not interested in a relationship. Or maybe he was married and that ended, and he’s really not interested in a relationship.
  • Thinning hair – He must be miserable and desperately searching for a solution to regrow his hair.
  • Works 80 hours a week – He must have a good work ethic, must be ambitious, and he must really enjoy his job if he puts in that much time
  • Manufacturing industry – in general, you’re not going to become a millionaire working in manufacturing, but if he’s working 80 hours a week, he’s probably in management, not working an assembly line. So he probably makes a decent income.

Now, are any of those assumptions true? Who knows! But by making them, we’re painting a very specific picture of our ICA that may or may not be accurate.

And what happens if we, say, invest a large chunk of our advertising budget into Facebook ads that are targeted to these demographics? It’s entirely possible that your money will go right in Zuckerberg’s pocket without seeing any conversions in yours. Why? Because if you only understand your ICA superficially based on high-level demographics, your ad copy and creative (images or video) will miss the mark – and your ad won’t get any clicks.

So what’s the solution? How do we get to know our ideal customer avatar without relying only on demographics that can slide into the stereotypical if we’re not careful?

The answer? Psychographics.

Psychographics is the study and classification of people according to their attitudes, aspirations, and other psychological criteria. Now, to be fair, psychographics can be stereotypical, too. Not all stay-at-home moms feel disconnected from others or themselves. Not all working moms wish they could be home with their kids. Not all single, 37 to 50-year-old balding men are in the market for a solution to their hair loss (case in point, Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson!).

But psychographics allow us to understand our ICA so we can serve them on a deeper level. For the working mom who doesn’t want to stay home with her kids, what kind of pressure is she feeling from society for the choices she’s made? Does she feel guilty that she loves to work? Does she feel like she’s neglecting her family because she can’t manage a home-cooked meal every night?

The key to psychographics is the same as the key to breaking down cultural barriers and destroying stereotypes – asking questions and being curious. My high school English teacher used to say that when you assume, you make an ass out of you and me, and he was right (and we all thought he was sooooo coooool because he said “ass” in class).

Asking questions and being curious keeps you from making assumptions. It helps you see the real people behind the stereotypes, to hear their stories, to understand their needs, and to connect with them on a deeper level.

And all that allows us to serve that ideal customer avatar so much more effectively – and it keeps you from wasting money on ads that are missing the mark with their targeting, copy, and creative.

So take demographics with a grain of salt and consider digging deeper into your customer’s or audience’s psychographics. Stop making assumptions based on culture and start connecting individually to really understand their needs, fears, desires, and pain points. Not only will this help you serve your customer better, but it will also help you increase your empathy for other people and your appreciation for other cultures.

Need help understanding your Ideal Customer Avatar based on their psychographics? Download my free .pdf, “15 Questions Your Audience Needs You To Ask” to start honing in on your audience’s attitudes, fears, hopes, and pain points – so you can serve them better!

LynleyH (1) cropped

Why Your Own Confidence Is A Gift To Others

By lynleyhipps

Confidence isn’t the same thing as bragging or showboating – confidence is about your own journey, the obstacles you’ve faced, and how you’ve overcome them. Your confidence inspires confidence in others that they can achieve their goals, too – so the more confidence you have, the more impact you’ll make!

Why Your Lead Magnet Delivery Email Needs a Makeover

By lynleyhipps

You know a lead magnet is essential for generating leads and building your email list…but did you know your delivery email could be even more important?

To Drip or Not To Drip…That Is The Question

By lynleyhipps

Should you drip your course content or release it all at once?

There’s not a hard-and-fast answer to this question – how you should deliver your course depends on a number of different factors…the nature of your course content, your audience, and even your personal preference. Check out my latest article for some questions you can ask yourself to determine the best delivery method for your course content.

Why are my Facebook ads being rejected?

By lynleyhipps

There are as many reasons that Facebook might reject an ad as there are stars in the sky, so you’re in good company. Don’t freak out. Don’t panic. Take a deep breath. Then ask yourself these questions.

Scroll to Top